Russell Gardens, N.Y., Code of Ordinances ch. 40A (eCode360 ed. 2026) § 40A-12
Presumptions applicable to rental registration enforcement and prosecutions
Operative Text
A. Within the context of rental registration enforcement and prosecutions, the presence or existence of any of the following shall create a rebuttable presumption that a dwelling is being used as a rental occupancy or an illegal multiple occupancy rental: (1) The dwelling is occupied by someone other than the owner, or the owner of the property represents in writing or otherwise, to any person or establishment, business, institution or government agency, that he resides at an address other than the rental property; (2) Utilities, cable, phone or other services are in place or requested to be installed or used at the dwelling in the name of someone other than the record owner; (3) There are separate entrances for segregated parts of the dwelling; (4) There are partitions or internal doors which may serve to bar access between segregated portions of the dwelling, including but not limited to bedrooms; (5) There exists a separate written or oral lease or rental arrangement, payment or agreement for portions of the dwelling among its owner(s) and/or occupants and/or persons in possession thereof; (6) Any occupant or person in possession thereof does not have unimpeded and/or lawful access to all parts of the dwelling unit; (7) There are two or more kitchens each containing one or more of the following: a range, oven, hot plate, microwave or other similar device customarily used for cooking or preparation of food and/or a refrigerator; (8) A dwelling has been advertised in any newspaper, magazine, local advertising publication, or posted or billed as being available for rent; (9) There are motor vehicles parked at the dwelling registered to a person or entity who is not the owner; (10) There is more than one mailbox at the dwelling; (11) There is more than one gas meter at the dwelling; (12) There is more than one electric meter at the dwelling; (13) There is more than one doorbell at the dwelling; (14) There are three or more motor vehicles registered to the dwelling and each vehicle owner has a different surname; (15) There are more than three waste receptacles, cans, containers, bags, or boxes containing waste from the dwelling placed for pickup at least twice during a weekly garbage pickup period; or (16) There is no electric meter annexed to the exterior of the dwelling. B. The presumptions set forth in Subsection A above, subject to the limitations contained therein, shall also be applicable to enforcement and prosecution of residential illegal use and occupancy violations. C. Nothing herein shall be construed to prevent persons living together as a family unit, with the owner, as defined by the Village Code.
Russell Gardens Code § 40A-12 establishes a list of observable conditions—such as separate entrances, multiple utility meters, non-owner vehicles, extra mailboxes, or evidence of a separate lease—that automatically raise a legal presumption that a dwelling is being used as a rental or illegal multiple-occupancy unit. These are 'rebuttable' presumptions, meaning the property owner can present evidence to overcome them, but the burden shifts once any listed condition is found. The same presumptions apply to enforcement of illegal residential use and occupancy violations, though the provision explicitly preserves the right of family members to live with an owner without triggering these rules.
Plain English — not legal advice.
Operators of residential property in Russell Gardens should be aware that § 40A-12 gives enforcement officials a broad toolkit: inspectors or prosecutors can point to conditions as routine as a second doorbell, an extra mailbox, or utilities billed to a non-owner as grounds to presume unlawful rental activity. A compliant property owner generally ensures that any occupancy arrangement is properly registered, that physical features of the dwelling are consistent with its registered use, and that documentation is available to rebut any presumption that might arise. Because the list of triggering conditions in § 40A-12 is extensive, operators typically conduct periodic self-audits of the property's physical characteristics and utility accounts.
General guidance for property managers — not legal advice for your specific situation. Consult an attorney for advice on your case.
Under § 40A-12, tenants living in Russell Gardens should understand that the physical and administrative features of their dwelling—such as separate entrances, individual utility meters, or a separate lease—can be used by the Village as evidence that the unit is a rental or an illegal multiple occupancy. If enforcement action is taken against a property, the existence of these conditions does not automatically mean a violation is proven; the owner has the opportunity to rebut the presumption. Tenants who believe they are affected by enforcement under § 40A-12 may wish to consult a tenant-rights organization or legal aid service to understand how such proceedings could affect their occupancy.
General guidance for tenants — not legal advice for your specific situation. Consult a tenant-rights organization or attorney for advice on your case.
Generated November 9, 2026 — auto-generated, not yet human-reviewed. See /transparency for methodology.
Effective Timeline
References Out
No outbound references recorded yet for this provision.
References In
Rules and statutes that cite this regulation